Jeremy Jordan, Andrew Keenan-Bolger and the cast of Newsies invited cameras backstage to show off a few of their prized possessions—gifts from their biggest fans, lovingly known as “Fansies.” While the cast members displayed everything from Chinese peanut butter, baby Swiss cheese, homemade trading cards, bowling pins, and more, Jordan’s fave fan gift made us happiest of all. The Broadway heartthrob, who is gearing up to star in TV’s Smash, proudly showed off his Broadway.com Audience Choice Award! Jordan took homes statue earlier this year for Favorite Actor in a Musical as well as Favorite Pair with co-star Kara Lindsay. Click below to check out Jordan and the cast have fun backstage with their favorite gifts from fans.